• ABONAMENTE
  • ASOCIATIA “ION CONEA”
    • SCOP
  • EDITURA
  • Librărie GeoPolitică
  • DONATIONS. SPONSORSHIPS. ADVERTISING
  • CONTACT

GeoPolitica

Portal de analize geopolitice, strategice si economice

  • HOME
  • REVISTA GEOPOLITICA
    • 2018
      • nr. 76/2018
      • nr. 75/2018
      • nr. 74/2018
      • nr. 73/2018
    • 2017
      • nr. 72/2017
      • nr. 71/2017
      • nr. 70/2017
      • nr. 68-69/2017
    • 2016
      • nr. 67/2016
      • nr. 66/2016
      • nr. 64-65/2016
      • nr. 63/2016
    • 2015
      • nr. 62/2015
      • nr. 61/2015
      • nr. 60/2015
      • nr.59/2015 EN
      • nr.59/2015 RO
    • 2014
      • nr. 58/2014
      • nr. 57/2014
      • nr. 56/2014
      • nr. 54-55/2014
    • 2013
      • nr. 53/2013
      • nr. 52/2013
      • nr. 51/2013
      • nr. 49-50/2013
    • 2012
      • nr. 48/2012
      • nr. 47/2012
      • nr. 46/2012
      • nr. 44-45/2012
    • 2011
      • nr. 43/2011
      • nr. 41-42/2011
      • NR. 40/2011
      • nr. 39/2011
    • 2010
      • nr. 38/2010
      • nr. 36-37/2010
      • nr. 35/2010
      • nr. 33-34/2010
    • 2009
      • nr. 32/2009
      • nr. 31/2009
      • nr. 30/2009
      • nr. 29/2009
    • 2008
      • nr. 28/2008
      • nr. 27/2008
      • nr. 26/2008
      • nr. 25/2008
    • 2007
      • nr. 24/2007
      • nr. 23/2007
      • nr. 22/2007
      • nr. 21/2007
    • 2006
      • nr. 20/2006
      • nr. 19/2006
      • nr. 18/2006
      • nr. 16-17/2006
    • 2005
      • nr. 14-15/2005
      • nr. 13/2005
      • nr. 12/2005
      • nr. 11/2005
    • 2004
      • nr. 09-10/2004
      • nr. 07-08/2004
      • nr. 06/2004
      • nr. 04-05/2004
    • 2003
      • nr. 02-03/2003
      • nr. 01/2003
  • BOARD
    • DIPLOMATS
    • NATIONAL BOARD
    • INTERNATIONAL
  • EDITORIAL
  • CLUBURI GEOPOLITICA
    • ExtraEurope
    • Club Geopolitica
    • New Silk Road
    • Geopolitica Club România
  • INTERNATIONAL SUMMER SCHOOL
  • 22/02/2019
You are here: Home / TOPICS / GEOHISTORY / VULNERABILITY OF A SMALL POST-COLONIAL STATE: GEORGIA’S INTERNATIONAL PROSPECTS IN 1918

VULNERABILITY OF A SMALL POST-COLONIAL STATE: GEORGIA’S INTERNATIONAL PROSPECTS IN 1918

by geopolitic.ro

Beka KOBAKHIDZE, PhD*

Just before the Great War the idea of political independence was distant from the Georgian political elite. It was an era of the Great Powers. International law of that time did not leave the space for self-determination and sovereignty of smaller nationalities. Even on the formal ground conquest of weaker by stronger was legal. Unlike today, there were missing practical tools like United Nations, Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, various peacekeeping and monitoring missions etc. Hence Georgia sandwiched between the Empires of Ottomans and Russia, located in the center of a turbulent region of the Caucasus, could hardly dream of the independence. Most of the political elites were varying in between political autonomy and cultural self-governance in their maximalist national claims.

The only chance to secure long lasting independence was to find a protector great power, but who would risk to counter the Russians and the Ottomans in the distant region of Caucasus? The Great War unexpectedly provided such opportunity: the Germans were targeting to facilitate an internal turmoil in Russia and force it to put down the arms. This would eventually allow the Germans to concentrate their troops on the western frontiers against the Allies and, moreover, to drive their march all the way to India, thus menacing there the British Orient. Thus, at the very beginning of the war the German Foreign Office and the Supreme Army Command ”Oberste Heeresleitung” sponsored national committees of the Baltic peoples, Finland, Georgians etc. These committees were forming paramilitary groups, preparing uprisings against the Russian Empire, recruiting prisoners of war of relevant origin etc. The German Empire was committed to grant independence to Georgia after the victorious war.[1] Nevertheless the most popular party in Georgia of the Social-Democrats stayed loyal to the Russian cause and declared their defensist position; they hoped for the democratic transformation of Russia and enhancement of national rights in the Caucasus. Pro-German Georgian Committee comprised of the Georgian rightists who later on shaped National Democratic Party. But those two made a deal that they would not go against each other and in the end one of their sponsors was to be a victor, thus they agreed that the both were working for the national interests.[2]

The Russian Empire was unable to handle years of intensive warfare and first the

 

Tsar was toppled in February 1917 and in October German sponsored Lenin overthrew the provisional government, thus inaugurating dictatorship of the Bolshevik Party. The Soviets withdrew Russia from the war, deserted Caucasus frontier and, moreover, according to the Brest-Litovsk Treaty of 3rd of March 1918 handed over Batumi and Kars provinces to the Ottoman Empire.

Bolshevik’s seizure of power triggered political secession of Transcaucasia from Russia. Georgians, Armenians and Azerbaijanis did not recognize the Soviet Government and first declared Transcaucasian Commissariat and then Transcaucasian Federative Republic. The Georgians and the Armenians, in frames of aforementioned stillborn entities, went in a war against the Ottomans in order to defend their territories from the conquest. Military power of the sides was dramatically unequal, hence Transcaucasia was menaced not only to lose Batumi and Kars, but also to be conquered in total by the Ottomans. That is where political connections with Germans, established by the Georgian Committee, were activated.

In the Great War Germany was an ally to the Ottoman Empire and was unable to afford ignoring Turkish interests. The Ottomans first of all were targeting the Armenian territories in order to materialize pan-Turkic ideas and drive the road to their Azerbaijani kinsmen; on the other hand the Germans were interested in Georgian manganese mines, Baku-Batumi railway and Baku oil industry. Consequently they were least interested in Armenia. German military attaché in Constantinople – General Otto Von Lossow, who was mediating between the Transcaucasians and the Ottomans, advised Georgians that the German Empire was unable to protect whole Transcaucasia and if Georgia wished to secure German protection it was expected to declare independence.[3]

* PhD degree at Ivane Javakhishvili Tbilisi State University in 2015, Associated Professor at Georgian Institute of Public Affairs (GIPA), Invited Lecturer at the University of Georgia and Caucasus University, Visiting Fellow at Russian and East European Studies of the University of Oxford

[1] See more details in: W. Bihl – Die Kaukasus-Politik der Mittelmachte. T. 1, Wien-Koln-Graz 1975; Lasha Bakradze – germanul-kartuli urtiertobebi pirveli msoflio omis dros (German-Georgian Relations During the First World War), Tbilisi 2010

[2] Noe Jordania – chemi tsarsuli (My Past), pp. 71-72, Tbilisi 2010; Revaz Gabashvili – rats makhsovs (What I remember), pp. 149-150, Tbilisi 1992.

Jordania was a leader of the Georgian Social-Democratic Party and Prime-Minister of Georgia during the independence years (1918-1921). Gabashvili was one of the leaders of the National Democratic Party.

[3] More on this topic see in: dokumenti i materiali po vneshnei politiki zakavkazya i gruzii (Documents and materials on foreign policy of the Transcaucasia and Georgia), Tiflis 1919; Baron Friedrich Von Kressenstein – chemi misia kavkasiashi (My Mission in the Caucasus), Kutaisi 2002. Kressenstain was a commander of the German troops in the Caucasus.

Share this:

  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Google+ (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Instagram (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: GEOHISTORY

About geopolitic.ro

Redactia revistei Geopolitica

ARTICOL INTEGRAL
Pe geopolitic.ro sunt publicate abstracte ale articolelor publicate în Revista GEOPOLITICA, care poate fi comandată pe www.geopoliticamagazine.com, în format tipărit sau electronic.

COMENTARII Cancel reply

AUTHORS

VĂ RECOMANDĂM:

GEOPOLITICS BOOKS

Revista GeoPolitica

MAPS

PARTENERI

Social Media

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
  • Google+

KEYWORD

Asia Centrală (26) Azerbaijan (27) Black Sea (43) carte (38) China (71) conflict (36) cooperare (29) criza (30) energie (29) energy (27) EU (44) Europa (35) European Union (40) geopolitica (159) geopolitics (60) globalizare (55) identitate (26) integrare (27) internationala (34) Irak (47) Iran (62) Islam (41) lansare (46) marea neagra (94) NATO (95) Orientul Mijlociu (29) petrol (25) putere (26) religie (26) Romania (184) Rusia (124) Russia (75) securitate (85) security (46) SUA (77) terorism (55) terrorism (34) Turcia (68) Turkey (43) Ucraina (55) UE (101) Ukraine (46) Uniunea Europeană (54) USA (31) şcoală (35)

COLEGIUL DE REDACŢIE

CONSILIUL ŞTIINŢIFIC
ACADEMIA ROMÂNĂ
academician Dan BERINDEI
academician Constantin BĂLĂCEANU-STOLNICI
academician Dan BĂLTEANU

ACADEMIA OAMENILOR DE ŞTIINŢĂ

Anghel ANDREESCU
Teodor FRUNZETI
Tasin GEMIL
Ionuţ PURICĂ
Gheorghe VĂDUVA
Constantin VLAD

INTERNATIONAL BOARD

Abdulrahman AL RASSI – Ministerul de Externe al Regatului Arabiei Saudite în Rusia
Alam ANWAR – Centre for West Asian Studies, Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi, India
Zeljko BJELJAC – Geographical Institute ”Jovan Cvijic”, Serbian Academy of Sciences and Arts, Belgrade, Serbia
Alex BERCA – analist economic, SUA
Christian BOLÍVAR – Chilean Army War College, Santiago, Chile
Maurizio BONI – Headquarters NATO Rapid Deployable Corps, Italy
Michele BRUNELLI – Università degli Studi di Bergamo, Italy
Come CARPENTIER DE GOURDON – World Affairs Journal, New Delhi, India
Michel CHOSSUDOVSKY – Centre for Research on Globa­lization (CRG), Montreal, Qc. Canada
Dimitrios DALAKLIS – World Maritime University, Malmö, Sweden
Nicholas DIMA – Selous Foundation for Public Policy Research, USA
Sevdalina DIMITROVA – National Military University ”Vasil Levski”, Veliko Tarnovo, Bulgaria
Serhiy DZHERDZH – NATO – Ukraine Civic League, Ukraine
Viacheslav DZIUNDZIUK – National Academy of Public Administration, Ukraine
Joseph E. FALLON – New York, USA
Tiberio GRAZZIANI – L’Istituto di Alti Studi in Geopolitica e Scienze Ausiliarie (IsAG), Roma, Italia
Pawel GOTOWIECKI – The College of Business and Entrepreneurship, Ostrowiec Świętokrzyski, Poland
Jaroslaw GRYZ – National Defense University and University of Finance and Management in Warsaw, Poland
Mara S. GUBAIDULLINA – Al-Farabi Khazach National University, Almaty, Kazakhstan
Serhii HAKMAN – Bukovinian Center for Political Studies, Ukraine
George (Sam) HAMONTREE III – Florida, USA
Radu HERVIAN – Drake Institute for Social Studies, Philadelphia, USA
Leonard HOCHBERG – Mackinder Forum, USA
Karolina ILIESKA – University St. Kliument Ohridski-Bitila, Faculty of Economics, Prilep, R. Macedonia
Slobodan JANKOVIC – Institute of International Politics and Economics, Belgrade, Serbia
David A. JONES – University of Warsaw, Poland
Thede KAHL – Institute for Romance Languages, Wien, Austria
Dincho KARAMUNCHEV – Geopolitics Consulting LTD, Bulgaria
Vladimir KARYAKIN – Russia`s Institute for Strategic Studies, Russia
Swapnil KISHORE – IDC Herzliya – International School, Israel
Yana KOROBKO – International Advisory Council of the Institute of Peace and Development, Canada
Tamara KOVAČEVIČ – University of Novi Sad, Serbia
Anatoliy KRUGLASHOV – Yuriy Fedkovych Chernivtsi National University, Ukraine
Matthew KWASIBORSKI – American Institute on Political and Economic Systems, USA
Dorin LOZOVANU – EGEA, Rep. Moldova
Sohail MAHMOOD – Preston University, Islamabad, Pakistan
Armando MARQUES-GUEDES – Direcção-Geral da Política do Mar, Lisbon, Portugal
Satoshi MORISHIMA – Middle East Cultural Research Institute, Tokyo, Japan
Isa MULAJ – Institute for Economic Policy Research and Analyses, Pristina, Kosovo
Elman NASIROV – Academy of Public Administration under the President of the Republic of Azerbaijan
John O`LOUGHLIN – University of Colorado, USA
Amanda PAUL – European Policy Centre (EPC), Brussels, Belgium
Charles PENNAFORTE – Universidade Paulista, São Paulo, Brasil
Donila PIPA – Faculty of Law, ”Vitrina” University, Tirana, Albania
Daniel PIPES – Middle East Forum, USA
Benjamin POGHOSYAN – Institute for National Strategic Studies – MOD, Armenia
Walter POSCH – Stiftung Wissenschaft und Politik, Berlin, Deutschland
Gaetano Mauro POTENZA – ”Geopolitical Review”, The Alpha Institute of Geopolitics and Intelligence, Italy
Maria PTASHKINA – National Research University, Higher School of Economics, Russian APEC Study Center, Moscow, Russia
Hans H. REISER – Regionalgeograph Donauländer, Deutschland
Charles SAINT-PROT – L’Observatoire d’études géopolitiques à Paris, France
Mohammed Saeed AL-SHAKARCHI – Ambasador Extraordinar şi Plenipotenţiar al Republicii Irak la Nairobi, Kenya
Steven Alan SAMSON – Helms School of Government Liberty University, Lynchburg, USA
José J. SANMARTÍN – Universidad de Alicante, España
Daniele SCALEA – Università degli Studi ”La Sapienza”, Rome, Italy
Musa SHTEIWI – Jordanian Center for Strategic Studies, Amman, Jordan
Gregory SIMONS – Centre for Russian and Eurasian Studies, Uppsala, Sweden
Vitalie SOCHIRCĂ – Universitatea de Stat din Chişinău, R. Moldova
Vladimir TESIC – Research Center for Western Balkan Security Issues, Serbia
Mohamad TROUDI – L’Institut International d’Etudes Stratégiques (IIES), Paris, France
Nuray TURKER – Karabuk University, Turkey
Tynchtykbek TCHOROEV (CHOROTEGIN) – Kyrgyz National University ”Jusup Balasagyn”, Bishkek, Kyrgyzstan
Andrei VOLOSHIN – Institutul de Economie Mondială, Lyov, Ucraina
Daniel WAGNER – Country Risk Solutions, Connecticut, USA
Immanuel WALLERSTEIN – Dept. of Sociology Yale University, New Haven, USA
Suolao WANG – Center for International & Strategic Studies, Peking University, Beijing, China
Jan WENDT – Institute of Geography, Gdańsk University, Poland
Shams uz ZAMAN – National Defence University Islamabad, Pakistan

NATIONAL BOARD

Constantin ANECHITOAE – Universitatea „Ovidius”, Constanţa
Cristian BARNA – Academia Naţională de Informaţii, Bucureşti
Dumitru BORŢUN – SNSPA, Bucureşti
Cristian BRAGHINĂ – Universitatea din Bucureşti
Anna-Eva BUDURA – Universitatea „Ovidius”, Constanţa
Irena CHIRU – Academia Naţională de Informaţii, Bucureşti
Dumitru CODIŢĂ – Asociaţia de Drept Internaţional Umanitar
Laura COMĂNESCU – Universitatea din Bucureşti
Olivia COMŞA – Centrul de Inginerie şi Tehnologie Obiective Nucleare
Dan DUNGACIU – Institutul de Relaţii Internaţionale al Academiei Române
Călin FELEZEU – Universitatea „Babeş-Bolyai”, Cluj-Napoca
Cornel GRIGORUŢ – Universitatea „Ovidius”, Constanţa
Constantin HLIHOR – Universitatea Creştină „Dimitrie Cantemir”, Bucureşti
Ioan IANOŞ – Universitatea din Bucureşti
Alexandru ILIEŞ – Universitatea din Oradea
Aliodor MANOLEA – Universitatea Hyperion, Bucureşti
Dumitru MIRON – Academia de Studii Economice, Bucureşti
Vasile NAZARE – Asociaţia de Geopolitică „Ion Conea”
Florin PINTESCU – Universitatea „Ştefan cel Mare”, Suceava
Nicolae POPA – Universitatea de Vest, Timişoara
Ştefan PURICI – Universitatea „Ştefan cel Mare”, Suceava
Nicolae RADU – Academia de Poliţie „Al. I. Cuza”, Bucureşti
Dănuţ-Radu SĂGEATĂ – Institutul de Geografie al Academiei Române
Vasile SIMILEANU – Academia de Studii Economice, Bucureşti
Laura SITARU – Universitatea din Bucureşti
Cristian TĂLÂNGĂ – Universitatea din Bucureşti
Cristian TRONCOTĂ – Universitatea „Lucian Blaga”, Sibiu
Răzvan ZAHARIA – Academia de Studii Economice, Bucureşti

REFERENŢI ŞTIINŢIFICI

Constantin ANECHITOAE – Universitatea „Ovidius”, Constanţa
Maricel ANTIPA – Universitatea Naţională de Apărare „Carol I”, Bucureşti
Cristian BARNA – Academia Naţională de Informaţii, Bucureşti
Adrian FILIP – Universitatea „Andrei Şaguna”, Constanţa
Constantin HLIHOR – Universitatea Creştină „Dimitrie Cantemir”, Bucureşti
Aliodor MANOLEA – Universitatea Hyperion, Bucureşti
Silviu NATE – Universitatea „Lucian Blaga”, Sibiu
Nicolae RADU -Academia de Poliţie „Al. I. Cuza”, Bucureşti
Radu SĂGEATĂ – Institutul de Geografie al Academiei Române
Vasile SIMILEANU – Academia de Studii Economice, Bucureşti

COLEGIUL DE REDACŢIE

DIRECTOR FONDATOR: Vasile SIMILEANU
Senior Editor: Vasile SIMILEANU
Redactor Şef: Cristina GEORGESCU (SIMILEANU)

Secretar Știinţific:
Aliodor MANOLEA
Secretar de redacţie: Monica MUŢU
Website: Andrei ŢURCAN
Remus DOGARU

Redactori: Alexandru DINU
Irina IONIŢĂ
Cosmin PĂCURARU
Coperta şi grafica: Vasile SIMILEANU

NOTES
Authors are directly responsible for the choice and presentation of data contained in the articles, of their authenticity and originality, as well as their own opinions. The wording and presentation of the text is not always the opinion of the GeoPolitica Magazine and are not binding in any way editorial responsibility.

Reproduction in whole or in part of any written or illustrative material in this publication is prohibited without a written permission from the publisher.

Editors assume no responsibility for the content of material submitted by sponsors.

GeoPolitica TV

GeoPolitica Copyright © 2015 - Log in